Quiet roads, lake communities, and the storied Smoke Rise estate enclave.
Not just serving Kinnelon. Living Kinnelon. Our kids go to the schools. We shop the local businesses. We know the streets by heart because we drive them every day.
Backed by broker/owners Jeff Montemarano and Jason Alan Amendolia (Kinnelon HS graduate), both Kinnelon residents. Between Jason and Lisa, we have two Kinnelon High School alums who grew up on these streets. Our leadership doesn't just serve this town. They live here. They graduated here. They're neighbors.
Contact a Kinnelon Preferred AgentCurrent MLS listings — updated daily. Click any property to view details, photos, and request a private tour.
Looking for Kinnelon NJ real estate? CENTURY 21 Preferred Realty is the local expert for Kinnelon, NJ in Morris County. Browse current homes for sale, get a free home valuation, or connect with a Kinnelon, NJ real estate agent who knows every block of Kinnelon.
Half our Kinnelon business is done by agents who wake up in Kinnelon every morning. When you list with CENTURY 21 Preferred, you are not just hiring a listing agent, you are hiring a neighbor.
Kinnelon is a 19-square-mile Morris County borough of roughly 10,300 residents — and one of North Jersey's most distinctive housing markets. Where many towns blur into highway-strip sameness, Kinnelon is mountain-and-lake country: winding roads under heavy tree canopy, gated lake communities tucked behind stone entrance markers, multi-acre wooded lots, and an unmistakable rural-luxury character that buyers will drive an hour out from the city to find. The borough takes its name from Francis S. Kinney, the tobacco magnate whose 1880s estate eventually became the gated Smoke Rise community at the heart of town.
Our Butler/Kinnelon office sits on Route 23 right at the Kinnelon border, and our team has worked this market for more than three decades. We know the lake associations, the road-end gate codes, the Smoke Rise rules, and exactly how a Fayson Lakes contemporary trades differently than a Smoke Rise estate or a Stonybrook colonial. That kind of granular market knowledge is the difference between a transaction that closes cleanly and one that falls apart in due diligence.
Kinnelon's housing stock is almost entirely single-family homes on wooded acreage, with three broad price tiers that reflect Kinnelon's distinct neighborhoods. Entry-level Kinnelon homes ($600K to $850K) tend to be mid-century colonials and cape-style homes in Stonybrook, Butterworth, and the non-lake sections along Kinnelon Road and Kiel Avenue. Mid-market Kinnelon homes ($850K to $1.5M) include Fayson Lakes properties with lake rights, updated colonials on larger lots, and contemporary builds in the borough's newer sections. Luxury Kinnelon homes ($1.5M to $3M+) are concentrated in Smoke Rise, on the largest wooded parcels across the borough, and in custom estate homes on the multi-acre lots that define Kinnelon's character. Working with a Kinnelon realtor who knows each neighborhood's pricing rhythm is critical, a Fayson Lakes contemporary trades differently than a Smoke Rise estate or a Stonybrook colonial.
Smoke Rise is Kinnelon's most exclusive neighborhood, a 600+ acre private gated community with its own lake, miles of bridle trails, tennis courts, and the historic Smoke Rise Club. Founded on the 1880s estate of tobacco magnate Francis S. Kinney, Smoke Rise homes sit on 1 to 5+ wooded acres and typically start at $1.2M for the more modest properties and reach $3M+ for the substantial estates. Architecture ranges from historic manors and stone-and-timber lodges to custom contemporaries and new builds. Buying in Smoke Rise requires understanding the association rules, the gate access system, the road easements, and the community culture, and selling here requires an agent who knows how to market to the specific buyer profile that seeks out a Smoke Rise home. Our team lives and works this market and has sold Smoke Rise properties for decades. See our dedicated Smoke Rise page for the full breakdown.
Beyond Smoke Rise, Kinnelon breaks down into several distinct pockets. Fayson Lakes is a lake association community with shared lake access, dock rights, and a mix of mid-century lake homes, year-round contemporaries, and newer custom builds — a Kinnelon favorite for buyers who want lake life without Smoke Rise pricing. Lake Kinnelon (called Stickle Pond by locals) and Butterworth are smaller, lower-key neighborhoods with their own quiet character. Stonybrook and the sections along Kiel Avenue, Boonton Avenue, Old Boonton Road, and Kinnelon Road offer substantial colonials and contemporaries on wooded lots for buyers who want Kinnelon's schools and character without a lake association. Each pocket has its own price band, so knowing where you're looking dramatically shifts what your budget buys.
Kinnelon Public Schools is consistently one of the top-ranked districts in Morris County and the broader region. The K-12 system serves about 1,800 students across Kiel School (K-2), Stonybrook School (3-5), Pearl R. Miller Middle School (6-8), and Kinnelon High School (9-12). KHS regularly sends graduates to top universities and has a strong athletic tradition. The schools are one of the primary reasons buyers with families specifically target Kinnelon — and one of the primary reasons sellers' homes hold their value here even when broader markets cool.
Despite its rural feel, Kinnelon is well-connected. Route 23 runs along the borough's southern edge, with quick access to I-287 (about 5–10 minutes), I-80, and Route 46. Lincoln Park Airport is just south for private aviation. Drive time to Midtown Manhattan averages 50–70 minutes depending on traffic. The Wayne Route 23 Transit Center offers NJ Transit Boonton Line service to Hoboken with PATH connections — typically 75–90 minutes door-to-door. Many Kinnelon residents work hybrid or in Morris/Bergen County offices and don't commute to NYC daily.
Per August 2026 New Jersey REALTORS data, Kinnelon's single-family market is a small-sample story worth understanding. 8 single-family homes closed in August 2026 versus 9 in August 2025, and the monthly median landed at $900,000, down 18.2% from a $1.1M August 2025. With so few sales, one or two estate closings move the monthly number; the bigger picture is the 2026 year-to-date median of $930,500, up 9.5% across 60 closings. Homes averaged 33 days on market and sold at 101.0% of list price, so well-priced homes are still selling at or above asking. Inventory sits at 20 active listings, a 2.7-month supply, still a seller's market, though buyers have more room to negotiate than in the spring.
Full breakdown: read our August 2026 Kinnelon market report for the complete numbers, trends, and buyer and seller strategy.
What Kinnelon's underlying pricing structure actually looks like: entry Kinnelon homes $600K to $850K; Fayson Lakes and mid-tier $850K to $1.5M; Smoke Rise and premium wooded estates $1.5M to $3M+. Kinnelon's overall pricing floor continues to be set by the Smoke Rise upper bracket, even when a given month's closings don't include one. For the full Morris County breakdown by price tier and neighborhood, see our June 2026 Butler/Kinnelon market report.
Within Kinnelon sits Smoke Rise — a 600+ acre gated community anchored by a private lake, miles of trails, and the historic Smoke Rise Club. Substantial homes on multi-acre wooded lots, a culture that takes some explaining, and a market our team has specialized in for decades.
Visit our Smoke Rise Page →Kinnelon's market spans a wider range than most North Jersey towns. Entry-level Kinnelon homes in Stonybrook, Butterworth, and the non-lake sections typically run $600K to $850K. Fayson Lakes and lake-community properties trade in the $850K to $1.5M range depending on lake rights. Smoke Rise estates start around $1.5M and routinely reach $3M+ for the most substantial homes. Per August 2026 New Jersey REALTORS data, Kinnelon's 2026 year-to-date single-family median is $930,500, above the Morris County median of $843,750, and Kinnelon-specific pricing depends heavily on which neighborhood you're in. Request a free home valuation for an exact figure on a specific home.
Per August 2026 New Jersey REALTORS data, Kinnelon homes are selling at 101.0% of list price with an average of 33 days on market. That means well-priced homes are still selling at or above asking in about a month. The August 2026 median was $900,000 on a small sample of 8 closings, so per-home price varies dramatically depending on which neighborhood the home is in and whether Smoke Rise properties closed in a given month; the year-to-date median is $930,500. Kinnelon's inventory is at 20 active listings, a 2.7-month supply, still favoring sellers of well-priced product.
Kinnelon is almost entirely single-family homes on wooded acreage; townhomes and condos are extremely limited. A small handful of townhouse/condo product exists but few transactions occur in any given year. Buyers looking for condo or townhouse inventory in the immediate area typically look to neighboring Butler, Pompton Lakes, or Riverdale, all of which have meaningful condo/townhouse markets and are served by the same Butler/Kinnelon office.
Technically any NJ-licensed agent can help you buy or sell in Kinnelon. Practically, Kinnelon is a niche market where the difference between a Kinnelon-specialist realtor and a generalist matters, especially in Smoke Rise. Understanding the Smoke Rise gate rules, association bylaws, lake rights across Fayson Lakes, road easements on wooded parcels, and neighborhood-specific pricing rhythm requires an agent who works the borough daily. Our Butler/Kinnelon HQ office at 1481 NJ-23 S sits right at the Kinnelon border and has represented Kinnelon buyers and sellers, including Smoke Rise, for more than three decades.
Kinnelon is a collection of distinct neighborhoods. Smoke Rise — the gated 600+ acre private community with its own lake and Club — is the most exclusive. Fayson Lakes offers a lake-association lifestyle with shared lake access and dock rights. Lake Kinnelon and Butterworth are smaller, lower-key. Each pulls a different buyer profile, and prices vary substantially across them.
Smoke Rise is a 600+ acre private gated community within Kinnelon — its own lake, miles of bridle trails, the historic Smoke Rise Club, and substantial homes on 1 to 5+ wooded acre lots. Originally developed from Francis Kinney's 1880s estate, it operates under its own architectural and use rules that aren't immediately obvious to outside agents. We've represented buyers and sellers behind the Smoke Rise gates for over 30 years — see our dedicated Smoke Rise page for the full story.
Kinnelon Public Schools is consistently one of the top-ranked districts in Morris County and the broader region. The K-12 system covers Kiel School (K-2), Stonybrook School (3-5), Pearl R. Miller Middle School (6-8), and Kinnelon High School (9-12). KHS regularly sends graduates to top universities and is one of the primary reasons buyers with families target Kinnelon specifically.
Drive time to Midtown Manhattan averages 50–70 minutes depending on traffic, via Route 23 to I-287 to I-80 or Lincoln Tunnel approaches. The Wayne Route 23 Transit Center is roughly 10–15 minutes away with NJ Transit Boonton Line service to Hoboken and PATH connections to Manhattan — typically 75–90 minutes door-to-door. Many Kinnelon residents work hybrid or in Morris/Bergen County and don't commute to NYC daily, which is part of why the town's quiet, wooded character works.
Kinnelon and Butler share a border (our office sits between them), but they're different markets. Butler is a walkable, denser borough with a Main Street character, smaller lots, and homes in the $450K–$600K range. Kinnelon is larger, more wooded and hilly, with bigger lots, more luxury inventory, top-ranked schools, and a much higher price range — particularly because of the gated Smoke Rise community. Many buyers consider both; sellers in either benefit from agents who genuinely work both markets daily.
Our Butler/Kinnelon (HQ) office at 1481 NJ-23 S sits right at the Kinnelon border and has worked this market — including Smoke Rise — for more than three decades. Call (973) 838-3600, walk in, or request a free home valuation to start the conversation.
Call our Butler / Kinnelon office at (973) 838-3600 or send us a quick note. We'll set up time to walk through your goals, the market, and what comes next — no obligation.
Get My Home's Value