A classic Passaic County borough with lake-town charm and an easy commute.
Current MLS listings — updated daily. Click any property to view details, photos, and request a private tour.
Pompton Lakes is a 3-square-mile Passaic County borough of roughly 10,800 residents — and one of the most distinctive lake-town markets in North Jersey. Where most of our market is mountain-and-forest character, Pompton Lakes is built around water: an interconnected system of lakes anchoring the borough, three rivers (the Wanaque, the Pequannock, and the Ramapo) converging to form the Pompton River, and a downtown that grew up around those waterways. The result is a tight, walkable borough where lakefront homes, a real Main Street, and family-friendly streets all sit within a few minutes of each other.
Our Butler/Kinnelon office is roughly 10 minutes from anywhere in Pompton Lakes and works this market continuously. The difference between a lakefront home with riparian rights, a lake-view home a block off the water, and a non-lake home in the borough is meaningful — and pricing follows accordingly. Knowing which is which matters.
Pompton Lakes' housing is largely single-family — capes, ranches, colonials, split-levels, and a meaningful inventory of lake-area homes from a range of eras. The Wanaque Avenue downtown is the borough's commercial and walkable heart, with independent shops, restaurants, and older homes nearby. The streets surrounding the lakes pull a premium for water access, lake views, or dock rights. The Lakeside Avenue corridor, the Cannonball Road area, and the streets near the borough beach are all distinct micro-markets with their own pricing dynamics. There's also newer construction inventory tied to the long-running redevelopment of the former DuPont site on the borough's south side.
Pompton Lakes operates its own K-12 district, which is one of the borough's primary draws for families. The district includes Lincoln Elementary, Lakeside Elementary, Lakeside Middle School, and Pompton Lakes High School. Unlike neighboring towns that share or send to other districts, Pompton Lakes kids stay in the borough's own system from kindergarten through graduation, which keeps the school community tight and stable.
Pompton Lakes sits at the intersection of major commuter routes. I-287 is roughly 5 minutes away, with onward access to I-80 and the Garden State Parkway. Route 23 runs nearby, and Routes 202 and 23 give direct shots into Wayne, Pompton Plains, and points east. Drive time to Midtown Manhattan averages 55–75 minutes depending on traffic. The Wayne Route 23 Transit Center is about 10 minutes away with NJ Transit Boonton Line service to Hoboken and PATH connections to Manhattan.
Pompton Lakes typically runs $450,000–$575,000 for well-maintained non-lake single-family homes, with starter capes and older split-levels available in the high $300s to mid $400s. Lake-area and lakefront homes can push significantly higher — $600,000–$900,000+ for properties with direct water access, dock rights, or premium views. The lake premium is real and consistent: it doesn't reverse in soft markets the way some discretionary amenities do, because lakefront inventory is finite.
For broader Morris/Passaic County market data — median sale prices, days on market, list-to-sale ratios — see our April 2026 market report.
Non-lake single-family homes in Pompton Lakes typically trade in the $450,000–$575,000 range, with starter capes and older split-levels available in the high $300s to mid $400s. Lake-area and lakefront homes can push significantly higher — $600,000–$900,000+ for properties with direct water access, dock rights, or premium views. Request a free home valuation for an exact figure on a specific home.
In our experience, yes — and the data backs it up. Lakefront and lake-area premiums in Pompton Lakes are real and consistent, and they don't reverse in soft markets the way some discretionary amenities do, because the inventory is genuinely finite. There are only so many lakefront properties, and demand stays steady. Whether a specific lakefront premium is worth it depends on the property and your plans, which is worth a conversation before you make an offer.
Pompton Lakes operates its own K-12 district — one of the borough's primary draws for families. The district includes Lincoln Elementary, Lakeside Elementary, Lakeside Middle School, and Pompton Lakes High School. Unlike neighboring towns that share or send to other districts, Pompton Lakes kids stay in the borough's own system from kindergarten through graduation.
Drive time to Midtown Manhattan averages 55–75 minutes via I-287 to I-80 or the Lincoln Tunnel approaches. I-287 is about 5 minutes from anywhere in the borough. The Wayne Route 23 Transit Center is roughly 10 minutes away with NJ Transit Boonton Line service to Hoboken and PATH connections — typically 75–90 minutes door-to-door.
The lake-area and lakefront streets are the consistent premium areas — Lakeside Avenue corridor, Cannonball Road, and the streets near the borough beach. The Wanaque Avenue downtown area pulls buyers who want walkable Main Street character. The redevelopment area on the borough's south side offers newer inventory. Each pulls a different buyer profile and price point.
Pompton Lakes is geographically smaller and more water-focused than neighbors like Bloomingdale, Wayne, and Riverdale. Its biggest differentiators are the lakes themselves and the borough's own K-12 school district. Pricing for non-lake homes is broadly comparable to Bloomingdale; lake premiums put it in a category of its own.
Our Butler/Kinnelon (HQ) office at 1481 NJ-23 S is roughly 10 minutes from anywhere in Pompton Lakes and works this market continuously. Call (973) 838-3600, walk in, or request a free home valuation to start.
Call our Butler / Kinnelon office at (973) 838-3600 or send us a quick note. We'll set up time to walk through your goals, the market, and what comes next — no obligation.
