Mountain views, lake homes, and the largest township in North Jersey.
Current MLS listings — updated daily. Click any property to view details, photos, and request a private tour.
Looking for West Milford real estate? CENTURY 21 Preferred Realty is the local expert for West Milford, NJ in Passaic County. Browse current homes for sale, get a free home valuation, or connect with a West Milford, NJ real estate agent who knows every block of West Milford.
West Milford is an 80-square-mile Passaic County township of roughly 24,300 residents — the largest township in Passaic County by area, and one of the most genuinely rural, outdoor-oriented markets within commuting distance of New York. The township is anchored by Greenwood Lake (a 7-mile lake straddling the NJ–NY border), surrounded by Wawayanda State Park, Ringwood State Park, and large tracts of Norvin Green State Forest. More than half of the township's land area is protected open space. For buyers who want real privacy, lake life, mountain views, or a primary home that feels like a vacation house, West Milford is one of the few places in commutable North Jersey where you can actually have all of it.
Our Butler/Kinnelon office sits about 15–25 minutes south of West Milford depending on which section, and we work this market continuously — particularly the lake-area inventory, which requires a specific knowledge base (water rights, lake associations, septic and well systems, seasonal property considerations).
West Milford's size means it's effectively a collection of distinct communities. Greenwood Lake is the township's largest and most desirable lake market — substantial waterfront homes, lake-view properties, and year-round residences range widely in price and condition. The lake itself stretches into New York State, with multiple community associations governing different sections. Upper Greenwood Lake is a separate, smaller lake community to the north with its own character. The Hewitt area (ZIP 07421) is more residential and connects to broader West Milford and surrounding state parks. Newfoundland on the western side feels more rural still. Beyond the named lakes, smaller lake-association communities (Pinecliff Lake, Lindy's Lake, Olde Milford Estates, and others) dot the township.
West Milford Township Public Schools is a K-12 district serving the entire township. The district operates multiple elementary schools (Apshawa, Maple Road, Marshall Hill, Paradise Knoll, Upper Greenwood Lake, Westbrook), Macopin School (middle), and West Milford Township High School. Despite the township's size, students attend one centralized high school, which keeps the school community connected across the geographic spread.
West Milford's trade-off is commute time. Route 23 is the main artery, running south through the township toward I-287 (about 20–30 minutes from most West Milford homes). Drive time to Midtown Manhattan averages 70–95 minutes depending on traffic and which part of the township you're starting from. NJ Transit Boonton Line service is accessible via the Wayne Route 23 Transit Center (about 25–35 minutes drive). West Milford works best for buyers with flexible schedules, hybrid work arrangements, jobs in the Route 23 corridor, or those willing to trade commute time for the rural-lake lifestyle.
West Milford typically runs $375,000–$525,000 for well-maintained non-lake single-family homes, with starter capes, mountain homes, and smaller properties available in the high $200s to low $400s. Lake-area and lakefront homes can vary widely — modest A-frames or cottages on smaller lakes from the $300s, substantial Greenwood Lake waterfront homes from $700,000 to $2M+ depending on lot, frontage, condition, and lake-association rights. The price point is one of West Milford's clearest advantages — you can buy substantially more home, land, or water access here than anywhere closer to NYC.
For broader market data, see our April 2026 market report.
West Milford typically runs $375,000–$525,000 for well-maintained non-lake single-family homes, with starter capes, mountain homes, and smaller properties available in the high $200s to low $400s. Lake-area and lakefront homes vary widely — modest A-frames or cottages on smaller lakes from the $300s, substantial Greenwood Lake waterfront homes from $700,000 to $2M+ depending on lot, frontage, condition, and lake-association rights. The price point is one of West Milford's clearest advantages. Request a free home valuation for a specific home.
Greenwood Lake is a 7-mile lake straddling the NJ–NY border, with the southern portion in West Milford. It's the township's largest and most desirable lake market — substantial waterfront homes, lake-view properties, and year-round residences. Multiple community associations govern different sections, and water rights vary meaningfully across the lake. Buying on Greenwood Lake requires understanding the specific association rules, water depth, dock rights, and seasonal access considerations.
Given its 80 square mile footprint, West Milford is effectively a collection of distinct communities. Greenwood Lake is the largest lake market. Upper Greenwood Lake is a separate lake community to the north. The Hewitt section (ZIP 07421) is more residential. Newfoundland on the western side feels more rural. Smaller lake-association communities (Pinecliff Lake, Lindy's Lake, Olde Milford Estates) dot the township throughout. Each pulls a different buyer profile.
West Milford Township Public Schools is a K-12 district serving the entire township. Multiple elementary schools (Apshawa, Maple Road, Marshall Hill, Paradise Knoll, Upper Greenwood Lake, Westbrook), Macopin School (middle), and West Milford Township High School. Despite the township's size, students attend one centralized high school, which keeps the school community connected across the geographic spread.
West Milford's trade-off is commute time. Route 23 is the main artery running south toward I-287 (about 20–30 minutes from most West Milford homes). Drive time to Midtown Manhattan averages 70–95 minutes depending on traffic and which part of the township. NJ Transit Boonton Line service is accessible via the Wayne Route 23 Transit Center (about 25–35 minutes drive). West Milford works best for hybrid workers, jobs in the Route 23 corridor, or buyers willing to trade commute time for the rural-lake lifestyle.
Three primary reasons: real privacy and acreage that's increasingly hard to find within commuting distance of NYC; lake life (Greenwood Lake especially) without leaving the metro region; and a price point that gets you substantially more home, land, or water access than anywhere closer to the city. The trade-off is a longer commute, but for buyers whose work allows it, West Milford is one of the few places that delivers genuine rural-lake character.
Our Butler/Kinnelon (HQ) office at 1481 NJ-23 S sits about 15–25 minutes south of West Milford and works the township continuously — particularly the lake-area inventory, which requires specific knowledge (water rights, lake associations, septic/well systems, seasonal property considerations). Call (973) 838-3600, walk in, or request a free home valuation to start.
Call our Butler / Kinnelon office at (973) 838-3600 or send us a quick note. We'll set up time to walk through your goals, the market, and what comes next — no obligation.
